Planning a trip to upstate NY and looking to enjoy some time on the water? The Finger Lakes region is an ideal destination for those with lake day desires, offering a variety of boat rentals including canoes, motorboats, and more for your next getaway.
The area is home to numerous types of family-run business dedicated to providing the best boating experiences, from single-day outings to multi-day rentals. You’ll find everything you need, from fishing poles for a quiet day of fishing to all the advice and equipment for longer adventures on the water. Whether you choose Cayuga Lake, Canandaigua, or another spot, you’re guaranteed a great time.
For anyone ready to explore the Finger Lakes, we have the information you need. With our lifetime knowledge of the area, we’ll help you find the top marinas and boat rentals. Plan your trip without worrying about the week or weather, knowing you have access to the best options for rental or rented boats.
Where to Stay When Vacationing at Finger Lakes?
Before you decide where to rent your boat, you have to find a nice place to stay. A comfortable lodging can make your getaway even more enjoyable. Check out some of our Finger Lakes vacation rentals for some fantastic options!
Listing #10 – Vacation Rental With 150 Feet of Private Lakefront
Keuka Park, Keuka Lake
Bedrooms: 4 | Sleeps: 12 | Bathrooms: 2 Full
O’Cottage offers a serene getaway on Keuka Lake, boasting 150 feet of private lakefront and unparalleled views in a secluded setting. This inviting property combines modern amenities with rustic charm, featuring multiple living areas, a fireplace, and spacious accommodations for up to 12 guests, ensuring a memorable lakeside vacation.
Listing #1039 – Holiday on Owasco
Auburn, Owasco Lake
Bedrooms: 4 | Sleeps: 8 | Bathrooms: 2 Full
Holiday on Owasco is a captivating lake house nestled on the shores of Owasco Lake, offering a tranquil escape with 60 feet of private, level lakefront. It’s perfect for families seeking a blend of modern comforts and lakeside charm, with air conditioning, a spacious kitchen, panoramic windows, and a design focused on guest experience and family gatherings.
Listing #83 – Lakefront Vacation Home With Jetted Hot Tub and Fire Pit
Keuka Park, Keuka Lake
Bedrooms: 4 | Sleeps: 12 | Bathrooms: 3 Full
Tranquility on the Bluff is an idyllic retreat perched on the serene Bluff Point of Keuka Lake, designed for privacy and relaxation. This spacious home offers a jetted hot tub, stunning lake views, and ample amenities for a memorable lakeside escape, accommodating up to 12 guests comfortably.
Listing #116 – Charming Cottage Overlooking Seneca Lake
Burdett, Seneca Lake
Bedrooms: 2 | Sleeps: 4 | Bathrooms: 2 Full
The charming cottage on Seneca Lake’s east side provides a picturesque retreat with stunning sunset views, featuring a private beach and boat dock. With its vintage charm preserved through various updates since its original construction in 1910, this cozy getaway offers a well-equipped kitchen, and a wood-burning fireplace, and is ideally located on the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, making it a perfect blend of secluded tranquility and convenient access to local attractions.
Listing #709 – Sunrise Cottage Waterfront Retreat
Seneca Falls, Cayuga Lake
Bedrooms: 2 | Sleeps: 6 | Bathrooms: 1 Full, 1 Half
Sunrise Cottage on Cayuga Lake offers a cozy waterfront retreat with gorgeous sunrise views, modern renovations, and comforts like a jetted hot tub, catering to families or groups of up to 9. Its prime location is perfect for exploring local wineries, breweries, and natural attractions, ensuring a refreshing and memorable lakeside stay.
Listing #1044 – 4-Season House & Beach
Keuka Lake, Finger Lakes
Bedrooms: 3 | Sleeps: 10 | Bathrooms: 2 Full, 1 Half
This beautifully restored Civil War-era home, set against the backdrop of Keuka Lake, offers a picturesque retreat with a large private beach and stunning lake views from every room. Ideal for all seasons, it’s cozy in winter with a gas fireplace and vibrant in fall with spectacular colors, providing a unique blend of historical charm and modern amenities, perfect for families or groups seeking both adventure and relaxation.
Canandaigua Lake Boat Rentals
Canandaigua is the fourth largest lake in the Finger Lakes region, covering more than 15.5 miles with forests around it. The area is full of activities, offering boat rental for short trips and multi-day rental for longer stays. Visitors can enjoy parks, the city pier, wineries, and a water park on Canandaigua Lake.
For a day on the water, consider renting a Cayuga Lake boat or water mats, perfect for relaxing and taking in the views.
1. Smith Boys in Jansen Marina
Smith Boys in Jansen Marina, a well-known chain in upstate NY, has a location on Canandaigua Lake. They offer a variety of services including boat rentals, fuel, and repairs. Their current fleet includes pontoons and tri-toons available for rent either daily or over multiple days. Make sure to enjoy a sunset on the lake during your rental time. They also provide all the necessary supplies satisfying a fun, safe, and comfortable experience on the water.
2. Reagan’s Canoe and Kayak Livery
Reagan’s Canoe and Kayak Livery operates across six of the eight Finger Lakes in NY, boasting the region’s broadest selection of canoes and stand-up paddleboards. They offer an array of boats, including pontoon types, ensuring they meet every customer’s needs. Whether it’s for a single day or an extended period, Reagan’s is ready to assist in matching you with the ideal boat at a competitive price. They also offer the convenience of possibly delivering your rental directly to your location, making it easier to start your adventure without hassle. Contact them to inquire about delivery options.
For those eyeing Canandaigua Lake as their next vacation destination, consider exploring our range of vacation rentals by owner to secure the perfect spot for your stay in NY.
Cayuga Boat Rentals
Cayuga Lake, nestled in Ithaca, New York, stands as the second-largest lake in the region, boasting a well-equipped marina and two yacht clubs. For those looking to explore the waters, this boat rental shop offers a wide selection of boats, including pontoon types, at a competitive price. Visitors can launch their aquatic adventures from key locations such as Myers Park and Stewart Park, enhancing their experience on Cayuga Lake, NY. Whether you’re aiming for leisurely lake exploration or engaging in water sports, this place provides everything needed for a memorable day on the water.
Our Picks for the Best Cayuga Lake Boat Rentals
Discovering the top boat rental companies on Cayuga Lake in the Finger Lakes region just got easier. With options for online rental or booking, you can effortlessly search and compare prices, ensuring you find the perfect fit for your family’s boating activities without overspending. Whether you’re looking for a single-day adventure or interested in multi-day rentals to thoroughly explore the waters, our curated list includes Cayuga boat rental, an establishment that stands out for its service quality and cost-effectiveness. From getting on board a pontoon for a leisurely cruise to engaging in more active water sports, these rentals provide everything you need for a memorable experience on Cayuga Lake.
1. Ithaca Boat Tours
Ithaca Boat Tours is a great place to go if you’re looking to explore, without having to drive, rent or take care of the boat yourself at Cayuga Lake. Sit back and enjoy the day! They have Wine on the Water, Farmers Markets, Picnic Lunch Cruises, Sunset Cruises, and even a Moonlight Cruise! You can also charter small motorboats!
Now that we’re done with the first of the many Cayuga Lake boat rentals available, let’s move on to the next.
2. Lockview Marina and Transport Company
Another option for the best NY Cayuga Lake boat rentals is Lockview Marina and Transport Company. It’s a great marina just a little bit north of the town of Cayuga. They sell gas right on the water and they offer boat storage and repair services. They also offer boat transport if you’re trying to head to a different place!
3. Finger Lakes Boat Rental
This Boat Rental serves the Cayuga Lake community and proudly carries a lifetime of boating and fishing experience on Cayuga Lake. In business since 2002, they are here to provide you with the perfect setup for your Cayuga boat rentals needs.
If you’re looking to make your next trip at Cayuga Lake NY then check out some of our lakefront vacation rentals.
Conesus Lake Boat Rentals
Shifting focus from Cayuga Lake boat rentals, we find Conesus Lake, a cozier member of the Finger Lakes family. Spanning 8 miles and reaching depths up to 66 feet, Conesus Lake is a favorite for both warm-weather activities like fishing and swimming, and winter pastimes such as ice fishing and skating. For enthusiasts looking to take to the waters, the lake offers an array of rental options including line Bennington pontoon boats, Sylvan fishing boats, and Chaparral deck boats. These choices ensure that regardless of your boating preference or the season, Conesus Lake has something to offer for every aquatic adventure.
1. Canadice Lake Outfitters
Canadice Lake Outfitters offers everything from canoes to dry bags. As a family business, they truly care about the community and their renters! Make sure you stop by for all of your needs for a fun boating experience.
2. Conesus Lake Boat Rentals
Conesus Lake Boat Rentals can pick up your boat or they will deliver it directly to your Conesus Lake rental! As another great family-operated business it cares about the community and its visitors. They try to make the process as simple as possible so that you can spend the majority of your time relaxing! You can rent a pontoon boat for tubing.
If Conesus Lake sounds like your ideal getaway then click here for more information on Conesus Vacation Rentals!
Honeoye Lake Boat Rentals
Honeoye Lake is known as the shallowest lake in the region with a mere death of 30 feet at its deepest point! It’s 5 miles long and less than a mile across. This lake lies between Canadice Lake and Canandaigua Lake. You can hike, and fish, and the water is typically calm. Since it’s one of the smaller lakes, boat sizes are restricted. It’s an ideal spot for canoeing or kayaking.
1. Canadice Lake Outfitters Canoe and Kayak Rentals
As mentioned above, they have a secondary location right off of Honeoye Lake. Rent your kayak or canoe with ease and go hit that water!
2. Reagans Canoe and Kayak Livery
Reagans Canoe and Kayak, which is another repeat on this list, has several locations. On Honeoye, Reagan’s offers stand-up paddleboard, kayak, and canoe. Don’t forget that they deliver all over the Region (within reason)!
If you’ve decided that Honeoye Lake is the spot for you, then check out our vacation rentals by owner for your perfect getaway!
Keuka Lake Boat Rentals
Keuka Lake is one of the major lakes of the Finger Lakes. It stands out due to its “Y” shape as opposed to the long narrow shape that the rest of the lakes in the region are. Due to its “strange” shape and size, Keuka Lake has an abundance of marinas and boat rental places.
1. Basin Park Marina
Basin Park offers speedboat, pontoon boat, and sailboat rentals. And they have recently moved to a new marina! They offer slips and docks as well. The Basin Park Marina rests on the north end of the lake over in Jerusalem, NY.
2. East Bluff Harbor
East Bluff Harbor has been a full-service working marina for over 40 years! Trust me when I say they know their stuff. Resting at the north end of the large part of the Y, Easy Bluff Harbor does rentals, service, and storage. They’ll even come to pull you in if you run out of gas or have a mechanical problem.
3. Jakes Boat Livery
Jakes Boat Livery is the best place to stop by for gas when you’re in the middle of Keuka Lake. It’s right down by the bend in the “Y” and offers gas, slips, and docks! It rests just south of the Keuka Yacht Club.
4. Keuka Lake State Park
Keuka Lake State Park has a boat launch and parking for up to 50 trucks and trailers. It is located on the north end of the west branch of Keuka Lake and is a great place to stop and explore! They have 651 acres of land and it is located near several great restaurants. Food is always a great way to end your day!
If Keuka Lake sounds like the lake for you then click here to check out some vacation rentals by owner in the area! Here, booking a reservation is a breeze.
Owasco Lake
Owasco Lake is one of the smaller, more shallow lakes in the region. This makes it the perfect spot for recreation! The water warms up more quickly than the other lakes and opens Owasco up to many opportunities early on in the season. Swimming, fishing, water skiing, and boating are popular on Owasco!
1. Owasco Marine
Owasco Marine stands out as the premier marina in the eastern region, offering an extensive range of services that include boat rental, purchasing options, winterization, and more. Whether you’re interested in renting a pontoon boat or a speed boat, Owasco Marine provides flexible options that cater to your needs, from a single great day on the water to an entire week of adventure. With a competitive price and a commitment to quality, renting from Owasco Marine ensures a seamless and enjoyable experience on the water.
2. Owasco Paddles – Boat Rental and More!
Owasco Paddles in Auburn, NY is a very dog-friendly place to rent your paddle boats. They have both a single and tandem kayak, Hobies, canoes, paddleboards, and paddleboats. You can rent by the hour, half-day, or full-day. The rental includes paddles, a safety whistle, paddle leashes
, and life vests–and if your best friend is coming with you they’ll give you a doggy life vest and a non-slip mat so they can enjoy the day on the lake as well!
3. South Shore Marina
South Shore on Owasco rests on the south end of the lake. South Shore loves fishing season and Owasco Lake is a great lake for fishing! They have boats for rent, repairs, and supplies as well as fishing supplies, bait, and tackle. Most importantly, South Shore Marina has a deli/snack bar! They’ve got anything you might need on your Owasco getaway.
Once you’ve decided to stay on Owasco Lake, click here to see what vacation rentals by owner we have to offer!
Seneca Lake
Seneca Lake holds the title of the largest glacial lake in the region and boasts the distinction of being the deepest lake in the state. Its reputation as the world’s lake trout capital is celebrated annually with the National Lake Trout Derby, attracting anglers from across the board. The lake’s unique microclimate has also made it a prime location for wineries, with an impressive count of 50 in the area. For those looking to explore the waters, rented boats are readily available, allowing visitors to operate their own aquatic adventure. Making reservations is straightforward, and a quick search will reveal the cost and options to best suit your plans for experiencing everything Seneca Lake has to offer.
1. Roy’s Marina
Roy’s in Geneva, NY has been family-owned and operated for over 65 years! Stop by here for fuel, storage, slips, fishing gear, and fishing charters. This is one of the places that offer rentals on boats, kayaks, and paddleboards! You can even grab your New York State fishing license from Roy’s Marina.
2. Stiver’s Seneca Marine
Stiver’s Seneca Marine is here for all of your boating needs. From fuel to kayak rentals they have it all. You can rent pontoon boat, kayaks if you want to go kayaking, or water skis and tubes to tow behind your boat. Once you’ve exhausted yourselves on the water make sure to stop by the Tiki Bar North to enjoy a beautiful summer sunset!
Is Seneca Lake the lake for you? Come find out by checking out some of our vacation rentals by owner! Booking a reservation is super easy and affordable.
Skaneateles Lake
1. Skaneateles Marina
Skaneateles New York can run you the vessel you need! They have paddle boards, stand-up paddleboards, and more. You can also rent a pontoon boat, a tube, and other items! They are also a full-service marina offering winterization, storage, rentals, life jackets, dock lines, and any other equipment you’ll need for your days spent on the water.
Click here to find out if a Skaneateles rental is the right choice for your next home-away-from-home!
Wrapping Up
The Finger Lakes is perfect for families with kids, and a great place for a weekend away under the sun–group or solo. We hope our list of Finger Lakes boat rentals above can help you plan your getaway with ease. And if you need to find a place to stay, do check out our gorgeous and affordable vacation rentals! Here, reservation is easy and with zero booking fee.
No Booking Fees!
No Commissions!
Direct Communication with the Owner
Browse and book vacation rentals on New York By Owner
(NewYorkRBO.com)
NEW YORK’S #1 FASTEST GROWING VACATION RENTAL LISTING SITE!